Fraud Report June 13, 2024
Troubling new opinion from the 9th circuit court of appeals on fraud. In US v. Milheiser the Court recently reversed the criminal conviction of several toner scammers. For years these companies called offices, told the receptionists that they were their regular supplier of toner for their copier, that the price was going up, but that they would send “more” at the old, cheaper, price. The victim companies had never in fact dealt with these scammers before. A jury convicted them of mail fraud.
The Court reversed the convictions, concluding that victims in fact did receive toner at the price disclosed in the call, thus concluding that the defendant’s lies were not “material” to victims. Needless to say, this decision is bound to cause trouble in future consumer protection cases, and I believe it is wrongly decided. But it reminds us that no matter what the legal standard is, it is important to have a solid theory of consumer injury – to explain why the lies matter to consumers.
Fraud Report June 6, 2024
WSJ: How a crypto romance scam cleaned out a senior citizen
Worth Remembering: Eighty years ago the allies returned to Europe in the landings at Normandy, with the largest Armada the world had ever seen. Thousands of brave men lost their lives in the desperate struggle on the beaches. I was fortunate to have known one man who was there on Omaha and lived to tell about it. I’m not at all sure that I would have been brave enough to have done this. So take a moment to think about them today.
Fraud Report May 30, 2024
Top Stories
New FTC report looks at which companies scammers are impersonating
- Most common are Geek Squad, Amazon, and Paypal
- But most money is lost to Microsoft for tech support fraud
- And to Publisher’s Clearinghouse for lottery frauds
- Biggest losses where victims send money by crypto or bank to bank wire transfer
- But gift cards most common way to pay in romance rauds, tech support fraud, and government impersonation frauds
Fraud Report May 23, 2024
Top Stories
- Calls offering payday loans but had to pay upfront
- Tech support calls resulting from Microsoft popups
- Calls claiming Amazon shipments had illegal contents and victim needed to pay to cancel or they would report to law enforcement
Los Angeles: Two Chinese men arrested for laundering $73 million from crypto romance frauds
Need an expert witness for consumer protection or fraud issues? Let me know.
Fraud Studies: Here are links to the studies I’ve written for the Better Business Bureau: puppy fraud, romance fraud; BEC fraud, sweepstakes/lottery fraud, tech support fraud, romance fraud money mules, crooked movers, government imposters, online vehicle sale scams, rental fraud, gift cards, free trial offer frauds, job scams, online shopping fraud, fake check fraud and crypto scams
Fraud Report May 16, 2024
Top Stories
Can I get rid of spam email? Under federal law those who send email have to have a working unsubscribe feature. The FTC enforces this. But I got some emails recently, and when I hit unsubscribe and found that I needed to reenter my email address. As you’ve probably guess I’ve since started getting a flood of spam. I’ve not seen any enforcement from the FTC for years against spam emails. This industry clearly has some organization, and some of my spam is on behalf of at least of some legitimate organizations like the AARP.
FTC warns that if someone claims your social security number has been used IT IS A FRAUD
Fraud Report May 9, 2024
Top Stories
Another troubling story about a fraud victim. As I’ve previously reported, 74 year old Ann Mayer was arrested for trying to rob a credit union in a Cincinnati suburb recently. She had a gun, had taken the license plates off of her car, and had mentioned robbing a bank to family members recently. She was arrested and charged. She had no criminal record. She got $500.
Family members say she was a scam victim herself, and had been sending money to an “unidentified individual.” News articles also say that she’d lost tens of thousands of dollars; others say she lost her life savings.
But we don’t know anything about the scam. Was this a romance fraud? Did the scammer encourage the robbery? Have they tried to track down the scammer?
India busts 76 tech support operations across the country, work with Microsoft and Amazon
Fraud Report May 2, 2004
Important case about older scam victim. I’ve reported before about William Brock, an 81 year old Ohio man who shot and killed an Uber driver who came to his house to pick up $12,000 for a grandparent scam. Apparently he had been told that his nephew was in a car crash in Charleston and had been arrested. Brock tried to get the phone from the Uber driver, which she refused, and he shot her when she tried to leave. Brock called 911, the police came, and the police answered two subsequent calls from the scammer, who said he was with the police himself. Brock is charged with felony murder.
The news articles give a few interesting facts
Apparently Uber assisted. The phone call to the Uber driver was from Canada, and was from a burner phone. And there are some questions the articles don’t answer/
- Was this the first time Brock had provided money in this scam?
- Was the Uber driver aware that this was a scam? Or was she simply being paid to pick up a package?
- Why did the scammer want to know what hospital the driver had been taken to?
- Was there any other useful information on her phone?
- Were they able to track the credit card number used by Uber?
New Australia Anti-Scam Centre issues first report, for 2023
- Complaints up 18.5%
- Reported losses down a bit from $3.1 billion to $2.74 billion
- Top frauds reported were investments (likely crypto romance fraud); tech support fraud, and romance fraud
Warnings issued across the US and Canada of huge spurt in text messages claiming fines are owed for speed cameras and road tolls. Example
FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center releases 2023 report on fraud against victim over 60
- Complaints up 14% over 2022
- Losses reported of $3.4 billion
- Tech support by far the most common fraud
- Biggest losses were in crypto investment frauds
- 15% paid by crypto
Fraud report April 25, 2024
Canada: CBC reports that Grandparent frauds in Canada have ties to the Italian mafia
Fraud Report April 18, 2024
Comment about revenge taken by scammers on victims by Professor Anthony Pratkanis: Historically, these sorts of revenge attacks on con grifters are not uncommon. That is why con criminals have developed extensive methods for “cooling out the mark” and “the blow-off.” And they seemed to do that in cases like this as well, either by hiring a legit Uber driver or by placing another (lower level) person who is in on the scam between them and the victim. I think people are becoming increasingly upset and angry at the level of fraud and scams we are all experiencing. A recent study found record levels of people reporting that they had been the target of a fraud attempt and a desire for action to be taken to stop these scams.
Russian hackers got access to emails between Microsoft and the US government
BBB updates my 2020 study on nonexistent vehicles sold online
- Complaints to the BBB jumped sharply in 2023
- Scammers also advertise campers, motorcyles, farm equipment
- New is scammers send people to a fake VIN search site, claiming to be like Carfax; victims enter credit card numbers, get charged
- Three quarters of victims over 45
- Original study here
Oxford and New South Wales Canberra release study on top countries responsible for cybercrime
In order, Russia, Ukraine, China, US, Nigeria, Romania, and North Korea